Property Description
Lake Life is calling with this custom built 5 bed 4.5 bath home on over an acre of serene living. With access to a shared easement and boat dock and pontoon available, Forest Lakes subdivision on Middlebury's north end is an idyllic place to live. Quiet cul de sacs, luminaries over the holidays, 4th of July fireworks over Hunter Lake, this neighborhood offers so much fun, and peace at the same time. This 6,000 square foot home has all the space you need for entertaining. With built in speakers inside and out, this home is perfect for hosting all your friends and family. Three of the generous bedrooms offer attached full baths. The additional two bedrooms are Jack and Jill style. Details like huge walk in closets, 3 window seats, a laundry chute, walk up attic storage, and massive windows are just a few amenities. The basement boasts a theatre room, a pool table, a wet bar, and a nook for cards or other games. The lower level bedroom with egress window, huge walk in closet and attached full bath is perfect for guests or an in-law suite. The storage and mechanical room has a separate stairwell that leads to the 3 stall garage, making for a great workshop or hobby space. The gorgeous eat in kitchen offers a double oven, 5 burner gas range, plenty of counter space and butcher block prep area, bar seating, and great views of the back yard and East Lake. Snuggle up in the Family Room with the wood burning fireplace and admire the expansive wall of windows and vaulted ceilings. There's also a 3 season room off the kitchen that would be suitable for a variety of uses and offers an abundance of natural light. A full size office at the front offers a quiet spot to work from home. With a new roof, guarded gutters, hot water heater, well pump, well bladder, refrigerator, dishwasher and newish furnace and AC, you couldn't have more peace of mind. Come see all this lovely home has to offer before someone else lands this dream.
Directions
East on HWY 120. Turn Right into Forest Lakes Subdivision. Follow Forest Lakes Dr to Butternut Dr. No sign in yard per sellers request.
Amenities
Attic Pull Down Stairs, Breakfast Bar, Built-In Home Theatre, Ceiling-Cathedral, Eat-In Kitchen, Garden Tub, Irrigation System, Kitchen Island, Laundry-Chute, Utility Sink, Wet Bar, Main Floor Laundry, Jack & Jill Bath
Sale Includes
Dishwasher, Microwave, Refrigerator, Washer, Window Treatments, Cooktop-Gas, Dryer-Electric, Kitchen Exhaust Downdraft, Oven-Built-In, Oven-Double, Radon System, Range-Gas, Water Heater Gas, Water Softener-Owned
Map to 10070 Butternut Drive, Middlebury, IN 46540
Property
| MLS # |
202606364 |
| Date Listed |
2026-02-28 |
| Status |
Active |
| Property Type |
Residential |
| Property SubType |
Site-Built Home |
| Finished Square Feet |
5997 sqft |
| Total Square Feet |
6312 sqft |
| New Construction |
No |
| Style |
Two Story |
| Type |
Site-Built Home |
| Basement |
Yes |
| Bedrooms |
5 |
| Bathrooms |
5
(4 Full, 1 Half)
|
| Annual Taxes |
$5,400.00 |
| Year Taxes Payable |
2025 |
| Year Built |
1997 |
| Virtual Tour |
propertypanorama.com »
|
| Days on Market |
49 |
Additional
| Cooling |
Central Air |
| Heating |
Gas, Forced Air |
| Garage |
Attached |
| Main Level Laundry |
Yes |
| Outbuilding |
Shed |
Room Dimensions
| Living Room |
22 × 27 |
Main Level |
| Dining Room |
12 × 14 |
Main Level |
| Family Room |
13 × 15 |
Main Level |
| Kitchen |
18 × 23 |
Main Level |
| Breakfast Area |
12 × 11 |
Main Level |
| Den |
13 × 15 |
Main Level |
| Master Bedroom |
16 × 22 |
Upper Level |
| 2nd Bedroom |
16 × 12 |
Upper Level |
| 3rd Bedroom |
14 × 14 |
Upper Level |
| 4th Bedroom |
12 × 13 |
Upper Level |
| 5th Bedroom |
12 × 16 |
Basement Level |
| Recreation Room |
15 × 17 |
Basement Level |
| Extra Room |
28 × 13 |
Main Level |
Bathroom Locations
| Full Baths |
3 Upper, 1 Lower |
| Half Baths |
1 Main |
External Features
| Construction |
Site-Built Home |
| Exterior |
Brick,Wood |
| Lot Size |
51,924 sq ft |
| Acreage |
1.19 Acre
|
| Lot Dimensions |
139 x 365 |
| Out Buildings |
Shed |
| Sewer |
Septic |
| Water |
Well |
| Fence |
None |
Location
| Area |
Elkhart County |
| County |
Elkhart |
| Subdivision |
Forest Lakes |
| Township |
York |
| City |
Middlebury |
| State |
IN |
| Zip |
46540 |
Schools
| School District |
Middlebury Community Schools |
| Elementary |
York |
| Middle School |
Northridge |
| High School |
Northridge |
Financial
| Financing Terms |
Cash, Conventional |
| Assoc. Dues |
$150.00 Annually |
| Assoc. Restrictions |
Yes |
MLS# 202606364
Listing Provided Courtesy of Kristin Bales
Listing Leaders, NCI-Plymouth
off: 574-842-4663
Listing updated April 2, 2026 at 2:45 pm
Last checked 25 minutes ago
IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.
Learn More About 10070 Butternut Drive