Sold for $158,000 Listed for $150,000
This property is not currently for sale or for rent.
Welcome home to 414 S Randolph Street in the heart of Garrett! This spacious 4 bed, 2 full bathroom, 2 story Victorian invites you to slow down and savor timeless charm. With 2,024sqft of finished living space, there’s space here for everyone—and every story yet to be written. Morning coffee feels better on the covered front porch, waving to neighbors as the day begins. Step inside to discover natural woodwork throughout, large sun-filled windows, and charming doorways that echo craftsmanship from another era. Each room offers warmth and character, blending historic detail with everyday comfort. Out back, a fenced yard creates the perfect setting for pets, play, or peaceful evenings under the stars. The detached garage adds convenience, while the manageable lot keeps maintenance simple. This property is offered as-is. Location? It doesn’t get better. Enjoy afternoons at West Side Park or East Side Park, family fun at Garrett Bowl, activities at the JAM Center, or tee off at Garrett Golf Course. Grab essentials at Dollar General and dine local at Auburn Garrett House of Pancakes, Shorty’s Steakhouse, The Grind Coffee House, or Lalos Restaurante Mexicano. National favorites like Subway and Pizza Hut are nearby too. Just minutes from I-69, with schools, banks, gas stations, and ATMs close by. Plus, neighboring Auburn offers expanded amenities including Planet Fitness, Anytime Fitness, Sonic Drive-In, Texas Roadhouse, Starbucks, Walmart, Kroger, The Home Depot, and care at Parkview DeKalb Hospital. Classic character. Convenient location. Your next chapter begins here.
On S. Randolph St. between Edgerton St. and Dennis St. on west side of street.
Ceiling Fan(s), Countertops-Laminate, Dryer Hook Up Gas/Elec, Landscaped, Natural Woodwork, Patio Covered, Range/Oven Hook Up Gas, Stand Up Shower, Tub/Shower Combination, Main Floor Laundry, Washer Hook-Up, Other-See Remarks
Sale IncludesDishwasher, Refrigerator
| MLS # | 202606321 |
|---|---|
| Date Listed | 2026-02-27 |
| Status | Sold |
| Property Type | Residential |
| Property SubType | Site-Built Home |
| Finished Square Feet | 2024 sqft |
| Total Square Feet | 2780 sqft |
| New Construction | No |
| Style | Two Story |
| Type | Site-Built Home |
| Basement | Yes |
| Bedrooms | 4 |
| Bathrooms | 2 |
| Annual Taxes | $1,397.78 |
| Year Taxes Payable | 2025 |
| Year Built | 1890 |
| Days on Market | 19 |
| Cooling | Central Air |
|---|---|
| Heating | Gas, Forced Air |
| Garage | Detached |
| Main Level Laundry | Yes |
| Pool | Yes |
| Living Room | 16 × 12 | Main Level |
| Dining Room | 15 × 13 | Main Level |
| Kitchen | 13 × 11 | Main Level |
| Master Bedroom | 12 × 11 | Main Level |
| 2nd Bedroom | 17 × 16 | Upper Level |
| 3rd Bedroom | 15 × 13 | Upper Level |
| 4th Bedroom | 13 × 12 | Upper Level |
| Full Baths | 1 Main, 1 Upper |
| Construction | Site-Built Home |
|---|---|
| Exterior | Vinyl |
| Lot Size | 5,663 sq ft |
| Acreage | 0.13 Acres |
| Lot Dimensions | 125x30 |
| Parking | Yes |
| Sewer | City |
| Water | City |
| Fence | Full,Picket,Wood |
| Area | Dekalb County |
|---|---|
| Location | City/Town/Suburb |
| County | Dekalb |
| Subdivision | Cowen(s) |
| Township | Keyser |
| City | Garrett |
| State | IN |
| Zip | 46738 |
| School District | Garrett Keyser Butler |
|---|---|
| Elementary | J.E. Ober |
| Middle School | Garrett |
| High School | Garrett |
| Financing Terms | Cash, Conventional |
|---|---|
| Assoc. Dues | $0.00 Not Applicable |
| Assoc. Restrictions | No |
MLS# 202606321
IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.
Listing Provided Courtesy of Warren Barnes
North Eastern Group Realty
Cell: 260-438-5639
Listing updated May 1, 2026 at 12:30 pm
Last checked 5 minutes ago